Plague was brought into the Jedi Order once he had shown talent in the force. During his years as a Padawan, he showed a large obsession with chemistry and alchemy. Wanting to expand his knowledge, he yearned to enter the Restricted Section of the Jedi Archives to learn the secrets of Sith Chemistry.
His patience would soon run out during his time as a Jedi Knight, as he asked his master if he could be let into the Restricted Section to study the art of Sith Chemistry. His concerned master consulted the Jedi High Council, where a vote was held, and after reaching their decision he was expelled from the order.
Fueled by rage and his obsession with learning more, he joined the Sith Empire, cast away his old life and face, now with a new identity, one in which he may perform his experiments and alchemy freely.